Monday, November 16, 2026
Does AI make you stupid?
As everybody knows, I use AI. After I have entered a question in my internet search engine, I get a webpage with at the top an AI-generated answer and then links to specific websites that treat the problem or question I want to be informed about. I think I don’t need to explain. It’s useful and helps me, for example, develop ideas and write my blogs. It saves me a lot of time, too. So that’s okay. However, increasingly it happens that the AI-generated answer doesn’t present only an answer to my specific question, but I get an answer that is already half a blog if not a complete blog, so to speak, and that’s not what I want. It’s true that once I have published here an AI-written blog, but I have told you that, and it was not because I was too lazy to write a blog myself, but it was a philosophical experiment, to see what AI would make of it. But as such, I don’t want that AI writes my blogs. I want only that it helps me when I need specific information. I want to write these blogs myself! Why? For you, of course; that is to share my – I hope creative and valuable – ideas with you, but – to be honest – in the first place I write these blogs for myself. My motto of these blogs is not only to make you think but even more to make myself think. This will not happen if I copy and paste AI-written texts. My feeling is that doing so would make that I don’t think anymore; it would make me less smart and less clever. So, I have decided to avoid AI if it takes my pen in its hands, and to use it only as an aid and not as a source.
Does AI make you really less smart and less clever? Yes, it does. Or anyway, if it doesn’t do so in an absolute sense it makes you less smart and clever than you would have been without using it. When you think less, your ability to think decreases, for thinking must be trained and maintained. Recent studies point in that direction. So in an experiment by Nataliya Kosmyna of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology three groups of students had to write an essay. Group A could use ChatGPT; group B could use the internet but not AI; and a third group C had to write the essay without the help of AI and the internet. In group C the brain appeared to be most active, especially the parts for creativity. The brains of those in group A were least active. Also when in a second round the members of group A had to write an essay without the help of AI or the internet, their brain activity stayed low. This could have been because those in group A used a new writing strategy not measured in a brain scan. However, when after their writing tasks the test persons had to tell what they had written, those in group A (the AI users) couldn’t, while those in groups B and C had no problem to do so. A survey of 26,000 secondary school Chinese students in 2022-24 had the same result. In the beginning those students who used AI in making their homework achieved high marks when tested but after half a year the test results had gone down by 20%. Students in a control group that used AI as an aid at most showed no relapse.
Does AI make you stupid or less smart? Using AI saves time, but what you learn doesn’t sink in. You tend to forget what you learn faster, if not much faster than what you learn without the help of AI. Or rather, if you use it without restrictions and unintelligently, for AI tools can be great instruments when used in the right way, that is in a way that it helps you think; not so that it replaces your thinking. Maybe the essence of the problems is as the German philosopher RĂ¼diger Safranski states: AI is perfect, but humans aren’t. If AI cuts the ground from under your feet, what remains then for you to do? Nothing. By doing so AI kills your thinking and creativity. In fact, it kills your brain, for a brain that doesn’t think doesn’t develop new neurological networks, but it “develops” only brain dementia. Another point is that AI doesn’t produce something new. It repeats in an “intelligent” way only what is already there on the internet. And then, if people publish on the internet only what they have written with the help of AI, will this not mean that AI-generated texts gradually will become simpler and more mediocre? Doesn’t AI then level off and flatten out what we already know? Doesn’t this mean that AI will undermine culture? Humans make mistakes but also think what others don’t think. Humans need to adapt to new and changing situations and find out new ways. These are the bases of culture. But AI is perfect and uses what is already there. One of the most stupid uses of AI I have recently heard of is that members of the Dutch parliament ask questions to the Dutch government with the help of AI or even let AI compose these questions, and that next the government answers these questions with the help of AI or even let AI compose the answers. A country governed by AI so by a machine?
Does this mean that we must not use AI any longer? Of course not. The point is to use it in an intelligent way; to learn when to use it and when not.
Sources
This blog is based on my own ideas and experiences; on what I recently read about AI; and on two articles in the Dutch daily De Volkskrant, which you can find here and here.

No comments:
Post a Comment